(Allentown/Lehigh Valley, Pa.)

April 5, 2007

Even if it's for polishing an image,
state spending cap is a bad idea

Diversion is a principle of politics. If there's an attack, counter-attack. If there's bad news, create some good news. And, if you need good news badly enough, don't be afraid to propose someone else's idea as your own.

Last week, state Sen. Bob Regola, R-Westmoreland, was charged with perjury, false swearing, reckless endangerment and illegal possession of a weapon following the shooting death of his son's friend. The Westmoreland County coroner ruled the death a suicide. Sen. Regola didn't enter a plea at his arraignment. His attorney, Duke George, said the senator is innocent and won't resign. However, if he is convicted of perjury, he would have to give up his Senate seat.

Thus, he becomes the latest member of the General Assembly with a legal cloud over his head. So, there is a need to shift the attention. Indicted one week. Propose reforms the next week.

This week, Sen. Regola introduced Senate Bill 7, a joint resolution to amend the state constitution to require spending caps on state spending. It's not an original idea. One of the planks of the several-years-old Jefferson Reform Initiative in the General Assembly is just such a cap. And, Sen. Mike Folmer, R-Lebanon, has proposed legislation to require the caps without a constitutional amendment.

Constitutional amendments take time. They must be passed in two sessions of the General Assembly before being submitted to voters. If a cap were in place now, says Sen. Regola, ''There would be no need to raise $2.5 billion in new revenue through seven tax increases'' proposed by Gov. Ed. Rendell. Under his proposal, the cap would limit spending increases to the average rate of inflation plus the average percentage change in state population over the previous three years.

Spending caps are a conservative nostrum and a lazy lawmaker's excuse for avoiding difficult taxing and spending decisions. Besides, the constitution already requires the governor and Legislature to pass a balanced budget every year. There's nothing stopping Harrisburg politicians from doing a better job controlling spending. They just lack the discipline to do so. Spending caps won't change that ... or Sen. Regola's legal problems.